Ratings
What each platform says, and whether they agree.
Above the Florida average of 4.52, across 346 pool builders.
Venice, Sarasota County
Financing through Acorn Finance, LightStream Named on their website, November 15, 2026.
What each platform says, and whether they agree.
Above the Florida average of 4.52, across 346 pool builders.
Read off their own website.
Where the work actually is, not just the office.
the bigger the dot, the more of their attention green is home shaded counties are where those towns sit
Three independent records, and whether they're still active.
Last sign of life November 2026, from a change to their website.
Straight from the state register.
The best and the worst from each platform. Both, always.
Pool Creations takes care of my pool weekly and has also drained acid washed and refilled the pool. They have a great staff that really does a good job. I had first signed up with Pinch a penny and they were absolutely awful. I was driving by Pool Creations stopped in and spoke to Sophia. I’m so glad I found them. They do a wonderful job.
BEWARE!!!!! BEWARE!!!! Take note of his response to my review....He trys to blame me and my family for his scam. Ask yourself this, if he was so good and honest as he tries to portray, why wouldn't he simply refund my over $14K deposit? Owners response below is packed with deceit!! He mixes lies with truth to convolute and deceive people. Don't buy into it!! TAKE NOTE ON ALL OF HIS 5 STAR REVIEWS AND THEN THE 1 STARS. No in between...It doesn't take a a genius to figure out this scam!! READ HIS CONTRACT THAT PROTECTS HIM AND HIS COMPANY. USES FAKE 5 star GOOGLE REVIEWS TO BOLSTER HIS SCAMMING BUSINESS!!! Most if not all reviews are fake! Companies hired to give fake reviews. Signed contract on November 9th 2023 for a pool remodel (new pavers, pool tiles, pool heater and re-surface of pool. Given a tentative start date of February 12th 2024 (Obviously very busy with a 3 month lead time). A very substantial deposit given ($14,387.75). When February 12th came around we were very excited to get it going. Well, no call, no email, no NOTHING! I called on February 16th and spoke with the so called "project manager" who spoke to me like I was a child asking me if I knew what "tentative" means. I told them just give me my deposit back. The owner "Ray" then called me and said he had a talk with the manager about his phone etiquette and told me I signed a contract and that it would be wise if I didn't break it. He said he would take half off my pool skimmer which I later learned he charged nearly $3,000 to do!!! WOW!!! What a deal eh? Had one put in at another home last year for $1400!!! On February 23rd 2024 a single man came out, drained my pool and chipped off the tile leaving me with an unsightly mess. As of todays date (March 11, 2024), no one has been back out. After giving them over $14,000 dollars for a mere DEPOSIT, they now want me to sign a document for coping stones which will then put my family on the hook for yet another $12,661.32. Their contract is worded in such a way that they are protected and us as consumers are at their mercy. THEY REFUSE TO RETURN THE DEPOSIT WITH THE OWNER (RAY) STATING HIS CONTRACTS ARE AIR TIGHT!!! THEY HAVE DONE NOTHING EXCEPT GIVEN US AN EYESORE TO LOOK AT When asked to put in writing an approximate completion date, the owner simply said "Oh I can't do that!" Unfortunately, I have had to hire an attorney and will seek out my deposit and find a reputable and honest company. Believe me, I'm cutting this short, there's way more to this story. Fast talkers (like greasy used car salesman) and very unscrupulous! I am a former detective for the Detroit Police Department and have done a little leg work. I have found at least 4 other residents facing the same problems. Also note a 5 star review by a "Peter Ryan" and a "J Fish" in the Google Reviews, coincidentally they have a Peter Ryan who was our salesman and a John Fisher who was the Project Manager. Another red flag or just a coincidence? You decide PLEASE BE CAREFUL WITH THESE GUYS!! A lot of SMOKE AND MIRRORS!!!
Professional equipment selection balanced performance with efficiency and thoughtful recommendations considered both immediate needs and long-term operational costs carefully
Told us we could get a 10' pool for 80K with no cage. The cage would cost 40K. Seemed outrages. Maybe we didn't appear like we would spend enough for their time. We just stopped in at the store on 41. It was not a formal consultation. An older woman with dark hair asked us what we wanted we said we wanted to get an idea about what it would cost to add a pool and that is what she told us. Talk to her. Definitely cost you a job.
Their construction methods exceed standards and superior building practices ensure structural integrity that will maintain our pool's safety and appearance indefinitely
Considering Pool Creations in Venice? See what their customers praise, the dispute worth reading and what to ask before a deposit — at Florida Pools Guide
Pool Creations is a pool builder with a storefront on South Tamiami Trail in Venice, Sarasota County. It holds certified pool contractor license CPC1458354, first issued in 2013, the same year the company says it was founded. They describe themselves as family-owned. The office is open weekdays, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., on (941) 366-6000, and the website is updated often.
They cover the whole life of a pool. New gunite construction is the headline, with infinity edges, tanning ledges, lighting, heating and saltwater systems all on offer. Remodeling, resurfacing, repairs and weekly service sit next to that, along with spas, water features, screen enclosures, outdoor living areas and commercial pools. Their site lists 11 awards from the Pool & Hot Tub Alliance on an awards page of its own. They advertise a ten-year structural warranty, so ask for that document and read what it covers. Twenty-four photos show the finished work.
Few companies say where they work as clearly. Pool Creations publishes separate, individually written pages for Venice, Sarasota, Nokomis, Osprey, Englewood, North Port, Port Charlotte, Punta Gorda, Boca Grande, Bradenton, Palmetto, Lakewood Ranch, Longboat Key and Holmes Beach. That's Sarasota, Manatee and Charlotte counties, top to bottom.
On Google they hold 4.7 from 78 reviews, above the Florida average of 4.52. Seventy-eight is a body of feedback big enough to rely on. Happy customers write about weekly service that fixed what a previous company left behind, friendly staff at the store, and equipment chosen with running costs in mind. The low reviews are few and each tells its own story. The most serious is a customer in a dispute over a deposit, which the owner has answered publicly. Read both sides on Google. Another came from a walk-in visitor put off by a ballpark price. Neither forms a repeated theme. The practical lesson is the usual one for any build: get the deposit terms, the refund terms and the payment schedule in the contract before money moves.
Claims on their site we could check against a record.
Their site carries a page of their own listing awards. We have not written to the awarding publications, so this rests on their own published record.
Their site carries a page of their own listing awards. We have not written to the awarding publications, so this rests on their own published record.
Florida licence CPC1458354 is on record and shows as Current.
7 photographs on record.
Photographs of Pool Creations’s work, from their own website. They remain theirs.
Starts with Pool Creations — Venice, Sarasota County. My project is somewhere else
Straight from their Google listing.
Answered from this record — not by the business.
Yes. Pool Creations holds Florida certified pool contractor license CPC1458354, first issued in 2013.
Custom gunite pools with features like infinity edges and tanning ledges, plus remodels, resurfacing, spas, screen enclosures, commercial pools and weekly service.
They hold 4.7 from 78 Google reviews, above the Florida average of 4.52. Most praise the service and staff. One recent review describes a deposit dispute that the owner has answered.
Across Sarasota, Manatee and Charlotte counties, with their own pages for towns from Bradenton and Longboat Key down to Punta Gorda and Boca Grande.
Ask for the deposit and refund terms in writing, the payment schedule, the build timeline and the full text of the structural warranty.
Verify anywhere.
Record last refreshed November 12, 2026. Compiled from public records and their own website.
| Fact | Source |
|---|---|
| The written profile | written for this record |
| Domain registration | the domain registry |
| Email address | their own website |
| Questions and answers | written for this record |
| First archived website | the Wayback Machine |
| Photographs | their own website |
| Where they work | our analysis |
| Google rating | |
| Opening hours | |
| Logo | their own website |
| Phone number | their own website |
| Summary | written for this record |
| Social profiles | their own website |
1744 S TAMIAMI TRAIL, Venice, FL 34293
Nearest first — the same town where we can, then the same county.
Is this your business? Claim this profile
to correct it, add photos and reply to reviews — free.
Something wrong here? Tell us.