Skip to content
Florida Pools Guide
6.3
Florida Pools Guide Score
median 6.8
★ 3.6 40 reviews · 1 platform
1license
2021licensed since
1county

Ratings

What each platform says, and whether they agree.

Google 3.6 · 40
3.60 / 5
40 reviews, across 1 platform

Below the Florida average of 4.52, across 346 pool builders.

About Caribbean Pools

Caribbean Pools of Lakeland: 3.6 on Google from 40 reviews, nearly a point below the Florida average, with two reports of no response after the build.

Who they are

Caribbean Pools works out of School House Road in Lakeland, Polk County. Their Florida contractor license, CPC057317, has been active since July 2021 — five years — while the domain was only registered in 2024, so the website is much newer than the business. They describe themselves as family-owned, which is their own account and not something the public record settles, and as licensed and insured: the license is real and current, insurance is not verifiable from outside any company, so ask for the certificate. Their home page was updated earlier this month, so the site is being tended even though it is recent.

What they build

New pool construction, renovation of existing pools, ongoing pool service, spas and hot tubs, water features, screen enclosures and outdoor living work. Seven lines, none with a page of its own, and twelve project photographs published. One thing the reviews make clear is that they also build for housebuilders: the most detailed positive account is from a customer who bought a new home with a Caribbean pool already installed. If your pool came with the house rather than from a contract you signed, they are still the firm that built it — which, given what the negative reviews say about getting hold of them afterwards, is worth knowing.

Where they work

Lakeland and Polk County. They publish no separate pages for individual towns, so there is no documented service area — Lakeland, Winter Haven, Bartow, Auburndale and the surrounding county is the sensible reading, and anything further worth confirming by phone. They keep short weekday hours, nine to four, and are closed at weekends. One thing to disregard: the Yelp page that our source list attached to this business belongs to a company in Arizona, so any Yelp figures you may see quoted for them elsewhere are not theirs. Google is the only reputation record we can vouch for here.

What the record shows

Google has them at 3.6 from 40 reviews, which is almost a full point below the 4.52 Florida average for the builders we hold — the largest gap on this list bar one. Forty reviews is a moderate sample: not the hundreds that make a score unarguable, but well past the point where two or three bad weeks could explain it. So the number is a real signal and should not be softened. What we cannot give you is a theme, because neither praise nor complaint cleared our reporting floor — three separate customers naming the same thing for praise, two for a complaint — and nothing here did. We are not going to invent a pattern to fill the gap. What we can do is tell you what the individual accounts describe, and they are strikingly consistent about one thing: getting a response after the pool is finished. One customer's pool light failed within two years, and their follow-up review reports a further thirty days and several more emails with no reply at all. Another, three and a half years after their build, went looking for someone to repair a heater and describes the same difficulty. Two separate people, both about after-sales response rather than the pool itself — and on the positive side, customers who describe the pool they got as genuinely good, one saying they shopped around for years before choosing them and that the family lives in it. That is the shape of this profile: the pools appear to be fine and getting anyone back afterwards appears to be hard. If you go ahead, the questions are all about after-handover. Who do you call, what is the response time in writing, what does the warranty cover on equipment specifically, and what happens if an email goes unanswered.

Where they work

Where the work actually is, not just the office.

the bigger the dot, the more of their attention green is home shaded counties are where those towns sit

How long they've been around

Three independent records, and whether they're still active.

Licensed
since 2021
Domain
registered 2024
Website
archived since 2024
Active

Last sign of life August 2026, from a change to their website.

License

Straight from the state register.

CPC057317
Certified Pool/Spa Contractor
Status
Current, Active
Since
2021
Expires
August 31, 2028
Qualifier
Timothy L Allore

Reviews worth reading

The best and the worst from each platform. Both, always.

★★★★★ Google · March 17, 2026

We purchased our new home with a Caribbean Pool already installed by Hulbert Homes. We weren't sure what to expect, since this was our first pool purchase. Jennifer and the team at Caribbean in Lakeland have been top-notch. They are responsive and have no problem going over things again and again for us as new pool owners. We installed the additional natural gas heater as an add-on after the original purchase of the home, and we had that done within two weeks. Caribbean Pools coordinated work nicely with Alternative Gas Construction and a local electrician.

★☆☆☆☆ Google · May 29, 2026

Worse company I’ve ever dealt with. They came in to do total resurface. Less then a year later major cracks. My wife and I have been trying to contact them for almost 2 years now. We have got nothing but run around and never a call back. The owner or anyone has come out to look. We’ve sent pictures to them and nothing but silence. If you want garbage work and no backing the warranty their the company to hire.

★★★★★ Google · January 9, 2026

Carribean built my pool in 2024. Our family literally lives in it. We shopped around for a few years before we decided to go with Carribean Pools. Best decision ever! I would rate higher than the 5 stars if possible! Jennifer and Tim were absolutely the best! If you are interested in adding a backyard oasis to your property.... look no further! 10/10!! 🏊🥽😍😁

★☆☆☆☆ Google · May 7, 2022

This is a followup to my initial review. It has been an additional 30 days with several addtional emails and still no response. Nothing. Stay away!!! My pool light stopped working after less than two years and is still under warranty. After one initial email response, nothing further has happened. I've sent at least five e-mails and left multiple voice mails with no response. This is extremely unprofessional. Buyer beware!!!!

★★★★★ Google · September 17, 2025

Caribbean resurfaced our pool and it is incredible! They know and take pride in their work. Every person we worked with from start to finish was knowledgeable, friendly, and the project was finished timely. I would highly recommend Caribbean Pools to anyone looking for a new build or resurfacing. You get more than what you pay for with Caribbean.

★☆☆☆☆ Google · March 21, 2022

They built my pool 3 1/2 years ago and at the time I fought the urge to leave a bad review but I was recently looking for someone to repair my heater when I came across Caribbean...all the negative experiences came flooding back and compelled me to write this. Taking possesion of my new build home was delayed for almost 2 months because of pool. House was built and ready but sat empty because we couldnt get CO until pool was finished. Then pool leaked for over 6 months and they insisted it was evaporation. Finally after dozens of calls and multiple visits from their people, they sent another company that had it fixed in less than an hour. Lights never worked properly from day 1 and they never fixed it. Again dozens of calls. Always the same excuses, waiting for parts, manufacturer is sending replacement, manufacturer wont send replacement, gonna upgrade your system with new lighting. Nothing ever happened. I ended up fixing lights myself by buying part off Amazon for $70. After about 3 months an area of my paver deck started to sink in. Took forever to get that repaired. Filter system always seemed to struggle with poor circulation. Eventually a big white ball of some hard material appeared in the pump basket and then circulation was much better. Notice a theme here? This company doesn't respond, doesn't fix your issues and doesn't follow through on their promises. I could go on for days. Do what you want but I would think twice before using Caribbean.

What they build

Read off their own website. 16 also appear in their photographs.

Features

Visible in their photographs: Deck jets Grottos Visible in their photographs: Spa Waterfalls

Extras

Visible in their photographs: Loungers Visible in their photographs: Raised walls Visible in their photographs: Sun shelf

Equipment and systems

Size and style

Visible in their photographs: Lap pools

Materials and finishes

Visible in their photographs: Pavers Visible in their photographs: Plaster finish Visible in their photographs: Stamped concrete Visible in their photographs: Tiles Visible in their photographs: Travertine

Shapes

Visible in their photographs: Freeform Visible in their photographs: Geometric Visible in their photographs: L-shaped Visible in their photographs: Rectangular

Quick Quote

Starts with Caribbean Pools — Lakeland, Polk County. My project is somewhere else

We want to make Quick Quote deserve its name. Unopened after an hour, it may pass to another licensed builder who covers the Lakeland area. Not to more than one at a time.

Hours Closed now

Straight from their Google listing.

Monday
09:00-16:00
Tuesday
09:00-16:00
Wednesday
09:00-16:00
Thursday
09:00-16:00
Friday
09:00-16:00
Saturday
Closed
Sunday
Closed

Questions homeowners ask

Answered from this record — not by the business.

What do the reviews actually say?

Google has them at 3.6 from 40 reviews, almost a full point below the 4.52 Florida average — a real signal on a moderate sample. No praise or complaint theme reached our reporting floor, so there is no pattern we can assert. But two separate customers describe the same difficulty: getting no response after the pool was finished, in one case a failed pool light and thirty days of unanswered emails.

What is the actual risk with them?

On the evidence, not the pool — the aftermath. Positive reviewers describe good pools, including one who shopped around for years before choosing them. The unhappy accounts are about equipment failing and nobody replying. So ask about after-handover specifically: who you call, the response time in writing, what the warranty covers on equipment, and what happens if an email goes unanswered.

Should the 3.6 rating put me off?

It should make you cautious and specific rather than decide for you. Forty reviews is enough that the score is unlikely to be bad luck, and a gap of nearly a point from the Florida average is substantial. Read the one and two-star reviews on their listing yourself, since that is where the detail is, and get every after-sales commitment in writing.

I have heard they have a bad Yelp rating. Is that right?

Not that we can confirm, and be careful with it. The Yelp page attached to this business in our source data belongs to a company in Arizona, not to them — so any Yelp figures quoted for Caribbean Pools of Lakeland elsewhere may well be somebody else's. Google is the only reputation record we can vouch for here.

Did they build pools for housebuilders?

Yes — the most detailed positive review is from someone who bought a new home with a Caribbean pool already installed. If your pool came with the house rather than from a contract you signed, they are still the builder, which matters given how the negative reviews describe getting hold of them afterwards.

Sources

Record last refreshed September 2, 2026. Compiled from public records and their own website.

Show every source
Fact Source
The written profile written for this record
Domain registration the domain registry
Email address their own website
Questions and answers written for this record
First archived website the Wayback Machine
Photographs their own website
Geo census-rooftop
Where they work our analysis
Google rating Google
Opening hours Google
License record the Florida DBPR license record
Logo their own website
Phone number their own website
Summary written for this record

Where they are

625 School House Rd #2, Lakeland, FL 33813

Other pool builders nearby

Nearest first — the same town where we can, then the same county.

Is this your business? Claim this profile to correct it, add photos and reply to reviews — free.
Something wrong here? Tell us.